none
Growing to meet the needs of the Microsoft Answers Community RRS feed

  • General discussion

  • The teams responsible for Microsoft’s community forums including (Microsoft  Answers, MSDN, TechNet, Expression and the Microsoft brand forums) would like to make you aware of upcoming changes to the Microsoft Answers platform and share details as to some modifications to the user experience that you may see.  As our most active users and contributors we want to share this information with you ahead of time to prepare you for these changes and answer any questions that you may have.

    What is Happening and Why?

     As the popularity of social media increases, more customers are turning to Microsoft's online community forums to learn, solve problems and extend their capabilities with our software, services and tools.  This increase in popularity has led to many asks that are differentiated per audience. For Microsoft Answers, targeted at the consumer audience, we need to more fully support the consumer Q&A scenario and features and functionalities for our online service businesses like Windows Live.  For the MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums targeted at developers, IT Pros and Designers, the focus is to empower and incent the communities to contribute and seamlessly integrate the experience with the rest of the MSDN and TechNet platforms and applications (wikis, blogs, galleries,…).

    Today, Microsoft Answers shares the same forum infrastructure as The MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums. To sustain growth and provide an avenue for continued innovation around specific audience needs, we will be moving the Microsoft Answers forums to a new platform infrastructure.

    With this transition, there will be changes to the user experience for community members that participate on Answers as well as The MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums.  There will be no change in user experience for the community that solely participates on MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums.

     

    When Will This Happen?

    The date for this transition is targeted for Friday May 21, at 4PM PDT.  During this transition, the Microsoft Answers, MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums will experience downtime for a period of 4 to 6 hours.  This time is needed for necessary data migration and testing.  Users that navigate to the site will be directed to an outage notification page during downtime.

     

    Why is this happening now?

     With the recent release of Office 2010 and the planned retirement of public newsgroups beginning on June 1, 2010, the decision to make the Microsoft Answers transition before these events occur is intended to minimize additional change and impact on the community.

     

    Less than .1% of All Users Will Be Impacted:

    Only those users who are active in both Microsoft Answers as well as any of the other supported sites (MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums) will see any sort of change.

     

    What Will Be Impacted?

     While the vast majority of the functionality of the sites (Microsoft Answers, MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums) will remain unchanged, the transition will impact the following community features:

    Forums Feature Change

    ·         The ability for moderators to move threads to and from Microsoft Answers to the other brands (TechNet, MSDN, Expression and Microsoft branded forums) will no longer be an option.  Moving threads across TechNet, MSDN, Expression and Microsoft branded forums will continue to work as it does currently. 

    ·         The ability to share forums across brands between Answers and MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums will no longer be available.  Shared forums for TechNet, MSDN, Expression and Microsoft brand forums will continue to work as it does today.

    ·         Forum and thread list views ("My Forums", “My Forum Threads”, "Assigned Threads", "My Alerts") will be limited to either Microsoft Answers only or only the other brands (TechNet, MSDN, Expression and Microsoft brand forums).

    ·         Over a year ago, forums RSS changed from an older syndication endpoint to the forums user interface.  Since this transition, it has been recommended to move off the legacy syndication URL service.  However for customers that have not moved off yet, they will no longer serve Answers data.  Users that want RSS for a forum or thread will need to re-subscribe to the RSS from the Answers Forum’s RSS buttons.

    ·         Existing users will not need to create a new profile after the Answers platform splits from the existing STO platform.  Each current user will have their existing profile copied to the Answers platform and ready-to-access upon launch.

    Forums Recognition Points Calculation and Display

    Today, users’ recognition points are central across all brand forums. This has caused some confusion since Microsoft Answers forum contributors would also show up as top users in the MSDN and TechNet forums even though they may not have contributed much there.

     

    After the platform separation user’s points will be more aligned to their set of forums. Answers points will reflect work done and contributions only in the Answers forums. The other brands (TechNet, MSDN, Expression and Microsoft brand forums) recognition points will reflect contributions that were not part of The Microsoft Answers forums.

    For example, currently if a community member has 16,000 points (5 medals) for their contributions in The VB forums on MSDN, then their profile will show that they have 16,000 points (5 medals) when they log into the Office community on Microsoft Answers. Once the transition to the new platform for Microsoft Answers occurs, points will only be displayed for the contributions that have been made on the Microsoft Answers forums.  Points that have been accumulated for participation on MSDN, TechNet, Expression and the Microsoft brand forums will not be displayed in the profile on Microsoft Answers. This change is intended to accurately reflect the points and medals that have been accumulated for contributions specific to Microsoft Answers or MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums.  Because of this change the following behavior may occur:

    ·         Point totals may decrease as the points are split for contributions on Microsoft Answers or MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft brand forums.

    ·         Medals may decrease as they are awarded for a total of points accumulated.

    Once the platform separation takes place, points and medals will continue to be calculated in the same manner.  Moving forward, users will have different point and medal totals for these contributions on Microsoft Answers and MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft branded forums.  It’s important to note that points and medals will continue to be calculated for contributions across MSDN, TechNet, Expression and Microsoft branded forums.

    For additional information on how points are calculated be refer to the forums FAQ.

    The Forums-NNTP Bridge

    A number of users who use the NNTP Bridge to connect their newsreaders to the Microsoft forums will see a change to the existing user experience.  The current NNTP Bridge will continue to work for MSDN, TechNet, Expression, and Microsoft brand forums.  In order to access the Microsoft Answers forums from a newsreader, a new Microsoft Answers NNTP Bridge has been created. The new Microsoft Answers NNTP Bridge must be downloaded and installed in order to access the Microsoft Answers forums once the platform transitions occur. For users that participate in Microsoft Answers and MSDN, TechNet, Expression, Microsoft brand forums, both NNTP bridge clients will need to be installed and running.  The latest version of the Microsoft Answers NNTP Bridge will be accessible from the following link on May 21.

    If you have additional questions or comments please feel free to contact our team directly at fortrans@microsoft.com.   On Wednesday May 26, 2010 we are holding two Live Meeting events for your convenience.  The meeting invites are below and are an excellent arena for you to ask any questions you might have about this shift after you've had an opportunity to experience the changes.  We highly encourage you to save this to your schedule.

    _______________________

    Live Meeting Option #1: 8AM-9AM (PDT):

    (866) 500-6738 or +1 (203) 480-8000
    Participant code: 8178974

    Meeting Option #2: 5PM-6PM (PDT):

    (866) 500-6738 or +1 (203) 480-8000
    Participant code: 8178974

    _______________________

     

    We're appreciative of the contributions and knowledge that you share in our online communities.

    Thank you,

    The Microsoft Online Forums Community Team


    Community Forums Program Manager
    Sunday, May 23, 2010 6:38 PM
    Answerer

All replies

  • I also noticed another thing, I may be wrong. Earlier Recent Visitors, Recent MOderators, Top Answers, Top Microsoft Answers and Top MVP Answeers in sub forum also. Now they have disappeared, only on root level foum they are appearing. Have they removed intentionally or still in process will appear in couple of days?
    Monday, May 24, 2010 8:38 PM
  • I really do not want to be too "snarky" here, but with a staff of developers, along with myself, often turning to MSDN for answers and Microsoft supposed to be one of the 'best' software companies out there, all these changes mentioned seem rather silly when there are two very distinct problems with the entire MSDN and Microsoft overall Forums.

    #1 - the MOST common answer we get on MSDN is that our questions are not in the right forum.  9 times out of 10 that we ask a question, this is the reply we get.  It is getting to a point where its better to simply post a question in 10 or 20 forums and hope for the best.  It is extremely odd and should be embarrasing to Microsoft that the other major software vendors we deal wtih (SAP, Oracle, etc) ALL have support forums where the Moderators (NOT the question-askers) can move a question for you.  Microsoft STILL does not support this and thus, using MSDN for important support questions is rarely fruitful - instead you spend days dancing all over forums simply because Microsoft's own Moderators cant move a question for you.  MS should understand that with Forums so poorly managed and named, how the heck are WE (users) to know the 'best' place to post!

    #2 - it is simply astounding to me how (pardon me, but) lame Microsoft's own support people are.  Example?  I asked a simple question; "What does Microsoft recommend for playing AVI files on XP, Vista and Win7" - I still cannot get an answer to this.  The common controls that used to work in XP dont work in Vista or Win7 - Microsoft ITSELF must have solved this problem since some of its own software seems to work fine playing AVI files on any of these OS's - but try to get that answer and you'd think you were asking someone to explain the event horizon of a black hole.

    The MSDN and TechNet forums are not only becoming useless, they seem to be designed so that you WONT get any working answer and remember - most of these posters are asking questions with an IMMEDIATE need.  We are finding more and more that by simply using Google and searching that way, one gets many more excellent answers than even ones coming from the MS forums.

    Why is it then when asking simple questions, these MS responders cant pick up a phone and ask someone in the development group the same simple question - this seems SO basic!

    In the last year we have resorted to two direct phone support calls to Microsoft on SIMPLE issues.  Issues that should have been documented, issues that should have been easily resolved and in the end - BOTH issues turned out to be MS's own bugs.  Thankfully we were not charged for either call.

    The impression generating out here - and I see this in my team as well as in friends in the business - is that Microsoft is hopelessly lost in selling inferior products that no one seems to know much about.  MS staff is very quick to 'defend' that they are dedicated to users, but in practice this does not come through at all and worse, they seem most dedicated to simply saying "wrong forum" and not being able to answer what are the most simple questions.

    If there is any way this can change, I would support it whole-heartedly.  I have over 30 years in this business and all of it with MS products - but lately, in the last 5-10 years, MS has nose-dived and seems almost totally focused on selling new stuff and simply no longer focused on supporting what they already made.  In the normal course of business this would put any such business out of business very quickly, but of course MS is huge and pervasive - and the result is they dont seem to see this, or care much about it.  We get announcements about "improvements" that fall way to short (as seen here) and MS staff seem to think this is a good thing.

    Its not.  In the normal world, success is in the eye of the beholder - NOT the ones presenting what gets beheld.  How MS lost this simple logic somewhere along the way, is beyond me.  Although most suggest this took place because Bill Gates left, and Ballmer took over - sales, sales, sales, and we'll get it right later (if we havent already replaced the version).

    I pray this changes.

     

    Monday, June 28, 2010 3:16 PM
  • Thank you very much for this valuable information. Otherwise most of would be scratching our heads without knowing what is actually going on.
    Regards Puboo My blog : http://thurupathan.spaces.live.com
    Wednesday, July 7, 2010 9:49 AM
  • A number of users who use the NNTP Bridge to connect their newsreaders to the Microsoft forums will see a change to the existing user experience.  The current NNTP Bridge will continue to work for MSDN, TechNet, Expression, and Microsoft brand forums.  In order to access

    louis vuitton / louis vuitton handbags /gucci

    Friday, August 27, 2010 1:15 AM
  • Hello dear all,

     

     

             This is Lilly Michelle. My topic is Microsoft suggestion forum. In this forum we learn about new microsoft versions and NNTP bridge connections. User experiences and sharings are accepted in this forum.

     

    _____________________________________________________________________________

     

    Want to get-on Google's first page and loads of traffic to your website? Hire a SEO Specialist from Ocean Groups  [url=http://oceangroups.org/] seo pecialist [/url]

    Saturday, August 28, 2010 6:38 AM