locked
GPO Computer and User setting conflict 問題 RRS feed

  • 問題

  • 如果GPO 中Computer setting 和user setting 有Conflict 的
    最後會係Computer overwrite user 定係user overwrite computer 架?

    我一直認為是Computer overwrite user (70-291 的書)
    但是今日看70-294 書就說是 user overwrite computer
    誰是誰非?


    in this book it said :
    if a setting is specified for a user as well as computer at the same GPO level,
    the computer setting always applies when it conflicts with a user settings

    Link : http://books.google.com.hk/books?id=hY8E8yLqEZAC&pg=PA565&lpg=PA565&dq=group+policy+conflict+user+computer%E3%80%80%E3%80%80&source=bl&ots=kN5BIeksah&sig=fAGEOtGe9kb-9Kz2bKKKR78eS_8&hl=zh-TW&ei=LUgjSpPMJdGUkAXUiqT6BA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2

    ---------------------------------------------------
    This Book said:
    if a user setting and a computer setting conflict, the computer setting is usually the winner regardless of the order in which the GPOs are applied

    Link : http://books.google.com.hk/books?id=msTrg8-kCu4C&pg=PA240&lpg=PA240&dq=group+policy+conflict+user+computer%E3%80%80%E3%80%80&source=bl&ots=ibbH5zu6fg&sig=oLPL0o4Y86VqCoTeR8wcFlLpL8c&hl=zh-TW&ei=qEQjSo3KDpKTkAXbm5D9BA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=9
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    and the other said :
    if there is conflict between the computer and user settings, the user settings will take effect. if ,for instance, a desktop setting is applied for the computer policy and different default desktop is applied for the user policy.
    the one specified in the user policy will take effect, this is because the user settings are more specific, and they allow systems administrators to make changes for individual user, regardless of the computer they're using

    2009年6月3日 上午 05:10

解答

  • Dear Customer,

     

    By default, the computer configuration has a high priority to user configuration. When there is a conflict between computer configuration and user configuration, the setting in the computer configuration will be applied in result.

     

    Hope this helps.


    Sincerely,

     

    Tom Zhang


    Tom Zhang – MSFT
    2009年6月3日 上午 09:59
    版主
  • yes , is the same GPO object i think.
    the order not local > Site > Domain > OU ?
    hoho forgot the local.... yes.. local should be the first. For same GPO.... the computer parts should be applied upon computer startup and the user parts should be applied during user logon, so I think user settings should override computer settings... unless the GPO is enabled with loopback processing...
    2009年6月5日 上午 01:06

所有回覆

  • Yap Ka Chun 你好

    最後應該是 as you said "Computer Override User"

    但係如果COPUTER 同USER 都是SEND 同一個SETTING
    這便會Depends on which rule you apply first. the latest one will override the previous settings.

    Please forgive me if my concept is not correct.

    Hope this can help.
    Chi
    2009年6月3日 上午 07:48
  • Dear Customer,

     

    By default, the computer configuration has a high priority to user configuration. When there is a conflict between computer configuration and user configuration, the setting in the computer configuration will be applied in result.

     

    Hope this helps.


    Sincerely,

     

    Tom Zhang


    Tom Zhang – MSFT
    2009年6月3日 上午 09:59
    版主
  • so the following description is not correct?

    if there is conflict between the computer and user settings, the user settings will take effect. if ,for instance, a desktop setting is applied for the computer policy and different default desktop is applied for the user policy.
    the one specified in the user policy will take effect, this is because the user settings are more specific, and they allow systems administrators to make changes for individual user, regardless of the computer they're using
    2009年6月3日 下午 12:49
  • GPO policies in the same GPO object? Don't know then... for different GPO, I think the order of applying is:
    Site -> Domain -> Computer -> User

    So GPO bind to user should overrides computer GPO unless you set the loopback processing mode of the computer GPO.
    2009年6月4日 上午 01:10
  • yes , is the same GPO object i think.
    the order not local > Site > Domain > OU ?
    2009年6月4日 上午 01:29
  • yes , is the same GPO object i think.
    the order not local > Site > Domain > OU ?
    hoho forgot the local.... yes.. local should be the first. For same GPO.... the computer parts should be applied upon computer startup and the user parts should be applied during user logon, so I think user settings should override computer settings... unless the GPO is enabled with loopback processing...
    2009年6月5日 上午 01:06